Unmasking Health Halos: When a Food Looks Healthier, but Isn't Necessarily Better
I talk about simple swaps quite a bit. Sometimes swapping one food for another is an easy way to add fiber, cut added sugars, or add more nutrients to your day. But I also want to be clear about something: a product that looks healthier isn't automatically a healthier choice.
This is where the idea of a health halo comes in.
A health halo is the positive impression we get about a food because of a particular ingredient, label, or marketing claim. Words such as natural, gluten-free, plant-based, high-protein, and non-GMO can make a product sound like a better choice before we've even looked at what's in it.
And food companies know that. They use these words, along with packaging, colors, and images, to influence how we perceive a product. That’s marketing.
This doesn't mean the claims are necessarily false; in fact, they are likely true. A gluten-free product may be essential for someone with celiac disease. A higher-protein cereal may provide more protein than the original version. A plant-based burger may be a convenient option for someone who wants to eat less meat.
But I tell people to consider whether those claims are meaningful. Saying that peanut butter is gluten-free feels like a no-brainer (peanut butter does not have gluten). So true, but is that even meaningful? All the other peanut butters are gluten-free whether they say it or not.
I've noticed more products using protein as a selling point. Protein Cheerios and other protein-fortified cereals may provide more protein, but that doesn't automatically make them a better breakfast. What about the added sugar, fiber, serving size, and the rest of the ingredients?
My point isn't necessarily to avoid these products. My point is to look beyond the words on the front of the package.
Here are some common health halos and what to consider before swapping.
Common Health Halos to Watch For
1. Gluten-Free Products
Gluten-free products are necessary for people with celiac disease and may be appropriate for others who need to avoid gluten. But gluten-free does not automatically mean healthier.
Some gluten-free breads, crackers, cookies, and snack products contain more added sugar or fat, less fiber, or fewer nutrients than their conventional counterparts. Others are nutritionally comparable.
If you need to eat gluten-free, choose products that meet your needs while providing good nutrition. If you don't need to avoid gluten, there's no nutritional reason to choose a gluten-free version just because it sounds healthier.
The FDA has specific requirements for foods labeled gluten-free, but that designation reflects gluten content, not overall nutritional quality.
2. High-Protein Products
Protein is having a moment, and food manufacturers are capitalizing on it. I’ve seen protein versions of cereals, snack bars, chips, pancakes, and just about everything else.
Take protein Cheerios as an example. The added protein may be useful, but it's worth comparing the product with the original. Does it also have more added sugar? How much fiber does it provide? What does the serving size look like?
A protein claim doesn't tell you whether a food is a good source of fiber, low in added sugar, or more nutritious overall.
Protein is important, but you don't need every food to be a protein food. Look at the whole product and consider what you want from that meal or snack.
3. Granola and Protein Bars
Granola bars and protein bars can be convenient, especially when you're traveling, working, or need something between meals.
But some commercial bars contain considerable amounts of added sugar and saturated fat. Others provide a good amount of fiber, protein, or both. And the calories can be significant.
Neither category is automatically better. Check the Nutrition Facts label, look at the ingredients, and consider whether the bar provides what you need. Sometimes a bar is simply a convenient snack, and that's fine. Just don't assume the word granola or protein makes it a nutritional upgrade. And if this is a meal replacement or substitute, keep that in mind.
4. Plant-Based Burgers and Meat Alternatives
Plant-based burgers and other meat alternatives can be great alternatives, especially for people who want to eat less meat or include more plant-based meals.
However, these products vary widely. Some provide protein, iron, and other nutrients, while others may be higher in sodium or saturated fat. Many are highly processed, although processing alone doesn't tell us whether a food is nutritious.
Compare the nutrition information, especially protein, sodium, saturated fat, and fiber. A black bean burger, for example, may offer a different nutritional profile than a meat-mimicking burger.
Both can have a place. The better choice depends on what you're looking for and why you're choosing it.
5. Pre-Packaged Smoothies
Smoothies can be a convenient way to include fruits and vegetables, but don't assume every bottled smoothie or smoothie mix is nutritionally equivalent to something made at home.
Some products contain added sugars, fruit juice concentrates, or relatively small amounts of actual fruit and vegetables. Others use whole fruit and retain much of the fiber.
Check the ingredient list and added sugars. And remember, blending whole fruit doesn't automatically remove its fiber or make it less nutritious. A homemade smoothie with fruit, yogurt, and other ingredients can be nutritious, but eating whole fruit is also a great choice.
6. Vegan Products
A vegan label means a product doesn't contain animal-derived ingredients. It doesn't tell you whether it's nutritious.
Vegan cookies, chips, crackers, and desserts can still be high in added sugar, sodium, or saturated fat. Oreos and Fritos are examples of foods that are generally considered vegan, and I enjoy both. But that doesn't make them healthier choices simply because they don't contain animal products.
A well-planned vegan eating pattern can be very nutritious. That doesn't mean every vegan packaged food is a nutritional upgrade.
7. Fruit Juice
Fruit juice can be part of an eating pattern, but 100% fruit juice differs from fruit drinks with added sugars.
Even 100% fruit juice contains naturally occurring sugars and provides less fiber than whole fruit. Whole fruit is generally the better everyday choice because it provides fiber and tends to be more filling.
If you enjoy juice, choose 100% fruit juice and watch how much you drink. You don't need to avoid it, but don't assume it offers the same benefits as eating the whole fruit.
8. Reduced-Fat Peanut Butter
Reduced-fat peanut butter sounds like an easy way to cut calories, but it doesn't always compare that way.
When manufacturers remove some fat, they may add sugar, starches, or other ingredients to maintain texture and flavor. Depending on the product, the calorie difference may be smaller than you expect.
Compare the ingredients, total calories, added sugars, and fat. Regular peanut butter is a perfectly reasonable choice. The fat in peanuts is primarily unsaturated, and you don't need to avoid it simply because you're trying to make a healthier choice.
9. Flavored Yogurt
Flavored yogurt can provide protein, calcium, and other nutrients, but it may also contain added sugars.
Like many of the foods I’ve noted, that doesn't mean you have to avoid it. If flavored yogurt helps you include yogurt in your day, it can be a practical choice. I usually have flavored yogurt when I eat yogurt on its own.
You can also choose plain Greek yogurt and add fruit, cinnamon, or a little honey or maple syrup if you prefer some sweetness. Just remember that honey and maple syrup still count as added sugar, too.
Compare the added sugars rather than assuming all flavored yogurt is a poor choice.
10. Multigrain Products
Multigrain sounds healthy, but it simply means a product contains more than one type of grain. Those grains may be whole, refined, or a combination.
If you're looking for whole grains, check the ingredient list. Look for whole wheat, whole oats, or another whole grain listed near the beginning.
A product can be multigrain without being whole grain. Those are two different things.
11. Non-GMO Labels
This is one of my favorite examples of a health halo because the label can suggest a nutritional advantage that isn't actually there.
A non-GMO label tells you something about how ingredients were produced. It does not tell you that a food has more nutrients, fewer calories, less sugar, or any other nutritional advantage.
Sometimes the label appears on foods that aren't realistic candidates for genetic engineering in the first place. Salt and water, for example, aren't genetically engineered.
The USDA's bioengineered food disclosure program provides information about certain bioengineered foods, but that designation doesn't measure nutritional quality or safety.
If knowing whether a product contains bioengineered ingredients matters to you, that's a personal purchasing preference. Just don't confuse it with a nutrition claim.
How to Look Beyond the Health Halo
So, how do you know whether a product is actually a better choice? You don't have to become an expert in food labels or spend 20 minutes comparing every item in the grocery store.
A few things can help:
Look at the Nutrition Facts label. Pay attention to serving size, calories, added sugars, fiber, sodium, saturated fat, and protein, depending on the food.
Read the ingredient list. Ingredients are listed by weight, so the first few ingredients can tell you quite a bit about what's in the product.
Compare similar products. Don't assume the one with the healthier-sounding name has the better nutritional profile.
Consider why you're buying it. Are you looking for more protein, more fiber, less added sugar, or simply something convenient? The answer can help you decide what matters.
Think about the overall eating pattern. One food or snack won’t make or break your nutrition.
And one more thing: I don't want you to walk away thinking all packaged foods are bad or that you should only buy whole, minimally processed foods. Convenience foods have a place. Sometimes a packaged snack, frozen meal, protein bar, or plant-based burger is exactly what works for your day.
Processing isn't automatically a measure of nutritional quality. The ingredients and nutritional content matter more than whether something comes in a package.
The Bottom Line: Don't Let the Marketing Make the Decision
I encourage people to make simple swaps when they make sense. Choosing a whole-grain product, adding more fiber, or finding a snack with more protein can be useful changes.
But a swap should offer something you're actually looking for. A gluten-free cookie isn't automatically healthier than a regular cookie. A protein cereal isn't necessarily a better breakfast. And a non-GMO label doesn't make a product more nutritious.
Food companies are trying to sell products. That's their job. Words and images on the front of a package are designed to get your attention and influence your purchasing decisions.
Your job as a consumer is to look a little further.
Read the label, compare products when it matters, and decide whether the food fits what you're looking for. You don't need to buy the product with the most health claims, and you don't need to avoid something simply because it doesn't have them.
Sometimes the original product is just as good as the supposedly healthier version. And sometimes the simple swap really is an improvement.
The difference is in the details.
References and Further Reading:
Health Literacy: How to Tell If a Nutrition Claim Is Actually Worth Paying Attention To
Whole Fruits Versus 100% Fruit Juice: Revisiting the Evidence and Its Implications for US Healthy Dietary Recommendations. Nutr Bull. 2025 Sep;50(3):411-420. doi: 10.1111/nbu.70009. Epub 2025 May 7. PMID: 40341750; PMCID: PMC12398644.
USDA Agricultural Marketing Service Information for Consumers: Bioengineered Foods
FDA Questions and Answers on the Gluten-Free Food Labeling Final Rule
Important Note: As of Fall 2026, the .gov links are accurate. However, there is a banner/heading that says NIH Websites Are Changing, so if these links do not work later, try searching by title.
Real World Nutrition Refreshed. As nutrition science and perspectives evolve, older blog posts are occasionally updated and republished. This post was originally written in December 2023 and has been refreshed and expanded here.